The fourth draft of the proposed contract handing administration of San Juan Island EMS over to the San Juan Island Fire & Rescue Dept wasn't ready until a few hours before the Public Hospital District #1 meeting. PHD Commissioners Warren Appleton and Anna Lisa Lindstrum both objected to discussing something they hadn't been able to read before the meeting.
Gene Wilson speaking at the PHD meeting September 25, 2019 Sharon Kivisto photo
Appleton said he wished he had known a fourth draft was being written as he had stayed up late going through the third draft and had 27 questions about that one.
Referring to the controversies that have plagued SJ EMS and the lack of transparency in drafting the contract, Appleton said, "This community has big wounds that need to be resolved. I don't understand what the hurry is....This is doing the community a disservice.... and is widening the wound."
After Lindstrum asked what the rush was, Edwards who lives part-time in San Diego County in California and was attending the meeting via Skype answered. He said, "This has been a work in progress for many, many years. We have an opportunity to strike a bargain."
The board agreed to table the motion after adding an amendment that they hold a special meeting to discuss the draft contract. Commissioners Rebecca Smith, J. Michael Edwards, and Mark Schwinge pushed to set one for next week. No date was set during the meeting. Smith said she would meet with PHD Superintendent Pam Hutchins to set one.
The public comment portion of the meeting occurred before the PHD Board discussed the draft contract. All six of the people commenting, urged the board to slow down.
Gene Wilson said, "I'm Frank Wilson's little brother." [The late Frank Wilson started EMS services on San Juan Island.] He noted the last time the two agencies were together it hadn't worked out as the fire district was more interested in the chrome on the wheels than they were in medical equipment needs.
He mentioned an article "Woman overboard, Customs Officer to the rescue" which includes this paragraph: [SJIFR Chief] Collins said the interaction between SJIF&R and SJ EMS was especially good. They were on the same radio frequencies and there was only one person in command. He said it bodes well for integration of the two departments. "That's the farthest thing from the truth," Wilson said. "I think maybe it's time for EMS to stand on its own," Wilson said.
Rick Frazier, who was one of five citizens who served for a year on the Citizens Advisory Committee that researched the idea of the two agencies consolidating, read a statement:
"My name is Rick Frazier and I wanted to address what I perceive as a premature takeover of the EMS System by the Fire System. It goes to the intent of a contract that was introduced at the Fire Department Board meeting last week and has been under development since early summer. As many of you are aware, I was part of the Citizen Advisory Group that was chartered to analyze the integration of the EMS System into the Fire System. The team spent the better part of last year and early this year interviewing many individuals and organizations and gathered a lot of information. One piece of information that was presented was the idea of an inter-local agreement to run the EMS System by the Fire Department while the integration was moving forward.
"At its conclusion the CAG released a document that recommended an integration with several absolute conditions to follow the recommendation. As part of the presentation to the board and public, it outlined its findings and a statement was made to the chair of the CAG, based on feedback to the committee and the committee's discussion, that an inter-local agreement would not be a recommended course of action.
"The reasoning behind the statement was the degree of complexity involved in bringing municipal organizations together that have different district boundaries, levies that need to be approved, and union contracts that need to be integrated, federal and state licenses that need to be transferred or obtained new. In addition, clinical policies, procedures and practices need to transfer, financial budgets (both operational and capital) need to be approved, current liabilities of the organization need to be disposed of and most importantly the acceptance and approval by the residents/share holders of both organizations.
"To date I am not aware that any of these issues have been accomplished or even planned out. I am not aware that any plans have been presented to the community and yet this contractual agreement puts the Fire Department and especially their employee, the new Fire Chief, as CEO of the EMS Organization. The contract spells out that the Fire Chief makes ultimate decisions and runs the EMS Organization. This contract is also being entered into just prior to a brand-new PHD board coming into office (within two months) which leaves the new PHD Board carrying all the liability and exposure of the Fire Chief's decisions without having a vote. And those decisions could carry heavy fines and potentially other penalties as this board is aware.
"While I believe many of the individuals involved in this process have good intentions about their decisions and direction, the ramifications of these actions as even demonstrated this week could have undetermined outcomes.
Gail Leschine-Seitz read a letter from all four of the people running unopposed for the four PHD Board positions up for election in November 2019.
"I'm here on behalf of the four hospital district candidates [Everett Clary, Trish Lehman, Kyle Loring, Leschine-Seitz,] running for office this fall to ask that you thoughtfully approach any proposal to transfer supervision of EMS to the fire district to ensure that it will result in the best possible medical care for our community. We understand that you may be considering relieving the interim EMS chief of his duties by contracting out those responsibilities. We believe that such a decision should not be rushed, especially given repeated statements by the two chiefs that they are working well together to explore the structure of an integrated fire/EMS district. If you do feel the need to enter into an agreement, we request that it embrace best practices and the public interest by:
1. Being the subject of discussion only at a meeting held at a time that working people can attend and only with proper public notice of at least two weeks;
2. Maintaining fiscal neutrality by decreasing EMS expenses in an amount commensurate with the contract costs;
3. Assuring that the fire district has the authority and all of the licenses/insurance/etc. necessary to oversee EMS;
4. Expressly indemnifying the hospital district and its commissioners in the event that fire district oversight leads to claims against the hospital district;
5. Allowing the commissioners to set the fire chief's reporting requirements to the hospital district; and
6. Including a provision allowing for-cause termination of the agreement, at a cost to be shared by both parties. In the current draft the term 'material breach' would need to be defined by both parties, so it is more accurate and clear.
Thank you for your public service, and we look forward to carrying forward the work you have done on behalf of our community.
- PHD suspends integration of EMS and SJIF&R
- San Juan Island Fire and Rescue Dept. response to PHD action
- Grout: Applauds decision by PHD to withdraw the EMS/SJIFR integration agreement
- Update on San Juan Island Fire & Rescue COVID-19 response and post pandemic response and service lessons learned
- San Juan County Fire District 3 Commissioners request annexation election postponement
- PHD to hold special meeting Nov. 12 in Friday Harbor
- Sharp: Don't put the cart before the horse with proposed EMS/Fire merger
- Dr. Geyman: Premature merger vote would be irresponsible
- Drath: Opposes hasty move by Schwinge, Edwards and Smith
- UPDATE: Fire won't sign ILA unless ALL PHD commissioners agree on it
- PHD Board continues rush to adopt contract, will meet Oct. 21 and 23
- Madsen: Urging PHD to slow down merger process
- PHD continues discussing EMS/Fire contract October 16
- Why are Smith, Edwards determined to turn San Juan EMS over to Fire in the next six weeks?
- Draft EMS/Fire contract put on hold
- Under proposed EMS/Fire contract: It's merger first, details later
- Highlights of CAG report on Fire and EMS integration
- Appears CAG is recommending SJ EMS integrate with San Juan Island Fire Dept
- CAG's decison on SJ EMS and Fire Dept. consolidation recommendation to be announced April 2
- SJ EMS Chief quits; recommends EMS join Fire Department