I am writing to urge the commissioners for Public Hospital District #1 (serving San Juan and several outer islands) to slow their head-long rush towards merging SJI EMS with Fire District #3. From what I can tell, three commissioners who are leaving the board in a month are determined to sign an inter-local agreement – a binding contract – which will leave many questions unanswered.
Worse, rushing into this inter-local agreement will force the merger BEFORE there is a funding mechanism in place, BEFORE the Town can vote on annexing themselves into Fire District #3, and BEFORE the differences in service territories between EMS and FD #3 can be rectified with respect to our neighbors on the outer islands.
And even worse than that: the agreement that a majority of commissioners are pushing to sign before leaving the board removes the ability of the board members that succeed them to alter the agreement or get out of it should annexation or levy lid lift votes fail. This is unconscionable, and runs counter to the idea that our elected representatives should be able to set policy and address problems.
The Citizen’s Advisory Committee, which thoroughly debated and investigated the issues involved and the detailed changes that need to be made, produced a comprehensive report on what needs to be done to merge EMS with the Fire District. Their plan, available at https://sjcphd.org/wpcontent/uploads/2019/04/CAG-Report-on-Possible-Integration-of-EMS-and-Fire.pdf, underscores the benefits that we can achieve by a smooth merger of EMS and the Fire District.
I agree with the CAG and others that a merger is sensible and will yield both service and economic benefits. I support the merger – done properly.
But I believe it is unwise to rush into a binding agreement just because three people are cycling off a board. The CAG report outlines what needs to be done, and as a community we should do what they outline, including a vote within the Town to annex into Fire District #3, a levy lid lift to ensure proper funding, and a plan to address the outer islands. Only then should we sign a binding inter-local agreement and merge EMS into Fire District #3.
If the commissioners pushing for a fast merger cannot agree to slow down, then I would ask that at least the provisions preventing revision or exit be struck from the agreement, so that this community has OPTIONS, should annexation or levy votes fail, or unforeseen issues arise during such a complex process. Thank you.
San Juan Island
- PHD suspends integration of EMS and SJIF&R
- San Juan Island Fire and Rescue Dept. response to PHD action
- Grout: Applauds decision by PHD to withdraw the EMS/SJIFR integration agreement
- Update on San Juan Island Fire & Rescue COVID-19 response and post pandemic response and service lessons learned
- San Juan County Fire District 3 Commissioners request annexation election postponement
- PHD to hold special meeting Nov. 12 in Friday Harbor
- Sharp: Don't put the cart before the horse with proposed EMS/Fire merger
- Dr. Geyman: Premature merger vote would be irresponsible
- Drath: Opposes hasty move by Schwinge, Edwards and Smith
- UPDATE: Fire won't sign ILA unless ALL PHD commissioners agree on it
- PHD Board continues rush to adopt contract, will meet Oct. 21 and 23
- PHD continues discussing EMS/Fire contract October 16
- Why are Smith, Edwards determined to turn San Juan EMS over to Fire in the next six weeks?
- EMS/Fire Dept draft contract tabled for at least a week
- Draft EMS/Fire contract put on hold
- Under proposed EMS/Fire contract: It's merger first, details later
- Highlights of CAG report on Fire and EMS integration
- Appears CAG is recommending SJ EMS integrate with San Juan Island Fire Dept
- CAG's decison on SJ EMS and Fire Dept. consolidation recommendation to be announced April 2
- SJ EMS Chief quits; recommends EMS join Fire Department